Difficulty
Beginner
Rate for accuracy
🎸
Intro:
Bm A D /F# G
Verse:
Bm A F#m G
They wrote it on a piece of paper, August 1989
Bm A D /F# G
From my grandad to my father, on that day, they made it mine
Bm A
It's been on the back of some jerseys
D /F# G
Beneath the lights on a marquee (marquee)
Bm A
Yeah, I'm proud of what they named me
F#m G
But some days I wonder why
Chorus:
Bm A
Is that third time always the charm?
D /F# G
Yeah, sometimes I'm not sure
Bm A
'Cause I got tattoos on my arms
D /F# G
And I barely go to church
Bm A D /F# G
I'm still trying to live up to the men I know they were
Bm A
'Cause they could've named me anything
D /F# G
But I'm James Mitchell Tenpenny
Bm A D /F# G
The 3rd
Verse:
Bm A D /F# G
Did they settle on it early, or did they choose it in the room?
Bm7 A F#m G
Would my brother have been named it if my blanket was pink instead of blue?
Bm A D /F# G
And if I ever have a boy, do I even have a choice?
Bm A D /F# G
Will he be asking these same questions if he's got my name too?
Chorus:
Bm A
Is that third time always the charm?
D /F# G
Yeah, sometimes I'm not sure
Bm A
'Cause I got tattoos on my arms
D /F# G
And I barely go to church
Bm A D /F# G
I'm still trying to live up to the men I know they were
Bm A
'Cause they could've named me anything
D /F# G
But I'm James Mitchell Tenpenny
The 3rd
Post-Chorus:
G Bm
Will I do it justice
G
By the time I'm gone?
Bm
Will it end with me
A Bm7 A D /F# G
Or will it carry o-o-o-on? (o-o-on) (o-o-on)
Bm7 A
Will it carry on? (o-o-on)
D G
Mmm mm, don't know
Chorus:
Bm7 A
Is that third time always the charm?
D /F# G
Yeah, sometimes I'm not sure
Bm A
'Cause I got tattoos on my arms
D /F# G
And I barely go to church
Bm A D /F# G
I'm still trying to live up to the men I know they were
Bm A
'Cause they could've named me anything
F#m G
But I'm James Mitchell Tenpenny
N.D . A F#m G
The 3rd
Outro:
Bm A
Yeah, I'm proud of what they named me
F#m G
But some days I wonder why
Song History
Published: July 15, 2024
Last Updated: September 10, 2025